3.37. AR400 Scientific Research Methodology (Mandatory)

3.37. AR400 Scientific Research Methodology (Mandatory)

Figure 3.37: Connection Map. AR400 Scientific Research Methodology

3.37.1. Justification Back to top

Scientific Research Methodology opens the research track of the specialization (Methodology – Statistics – Research Workshop – Research Work, ARC400-ARC403), giving every student the common, topic-independent toolkit – epistemology, research design, core quantitative and qualitative methods, theoretical-framework construction – before Research Workshop (ARC402) applies it to each student's own thesis topic and Statistics (ARC401) deepens the quantitative/instrument side. It differs in emphasis from the existing Architecture Research Methodology course (AR400), which focuses on evidence-based design and post-occupancy evaluation specific to buildings; this course instead targets territorial and urban-scale research problems.

3.37.2. Generales Goals Back to top

  1. Compare the epistemological foundations (positivism, interpretivism, critical theory) that underlie different research traditions applied to territorial and urban problems.
  2. Select and justify a research design (experimental vs. non-experimental; cross-sectional vs. longitudinal) appropriate to a given territorial or urban research question.
  3. Apply core quantitative research methods – survey design, variable measurement – to territorial and urban problems.
  4. Apply core qualitative and ethnographic methods – interviews, participatory observation, documentary analysis – to territorial and urban problems.
  5. Build a coherent theoretical framework (state of the art, conceptual framework) that grounds a research proposal.

3.37.3. Contribution to Outcomes Back to top

AG-A04) Communicates effectively and inclusively with the architecture community and society through reports, design documentation, and presentations tailored to different audiences. (Assessment)
AG-A10) Conducts studies of complex problems using research methods, experimental design, data analysis, and information synthesis to reach valid conclusions. (Assessment)

3.37.4. Content Back to top

3.37.4.1. Research Design and Methodologies (12 hours) [Skills AG-A10] Back to top

Bibliography: (Creswell and Creswell, 2018; Groat and Wang, 2013)

Topics

  1. Formulating research questions in architecture: descriptive, relational, causal; turning design problems into researchable questions
  2. Choosing a research methodology: quantitative (hypothesis testing, statistical), qualitative (interpretive, case study), mixed methods,
  3. Validity and reliability in architectural research: internal validity, external validity (generalizability), construct validity,
  4. Research ethics in architectural research: informed consent, privacy (anonymization of building users), institutional review board (IRB) protocols,
  5. Mixed methods research: sequential (qualitative then quantitative) and concurrent designs; integrating qualitative findings (user interviews) with quantitative data (occupancy

Learning Outcomes

  1. Describe the main research methodologies in architecture - quantitative, qualitative, mixed methods, practice-based - and explain their appropriate applications [Familiarity]
  2. Develop a research design for an architectural inquiry, including research question, literature review, methodology selection, data collection protocol, and analysis plan [Usage]
  3. Evaluate the research design of a published architectural study for validity, reliability, and ethical soundness, identifying methodological strengths and weaknesses [Assessment]
3.37.4.2. Theoretical Framework and Literature Review (12 hours) [Skills AG-A04] Back to top

Bibliography: (Creswell and Creswell, 2018; Groat and Wang, 2013)

Topics

  1. Systematic search of scientific and technical literature: specialized databases (Scopus, Web of Science, ASCE Library), keywords, and Boolean operators
  2. Critical reading and synthesis of scientific articles, technical standards, and prior research reports
  3. Building the conceptual and theoretical framework: defining key concepts, relationships between variables, and reference theoretical models
  4. Identifying knowledge gaps (research gap) and justifying the originality of the proposed contribution
  5. Bibliographic reference management and citation styles (APA, IEEE) using tools such as Zotero or Mendeley

Learning Outcomes

  1. Explain the structure and purpose of a theoretical framework within a civil engineering research project [Familiarity]
  2. Conduct a systematic search of scientific and technical literature on a chosen research topic using specialized databases [Usage]
  3. Synthesize the state of the art of a research topic into a coherent theoretical framework that identifies a knowledge gap [Assessment]
3.37.4.3. Quantitative Methods in Architectural Research (12 hours) [Skills AG-A10] Back to top

Bibliography: (Creswell and Creswell, 2018; Salkind, 2017)

Topics

  1. Survey design for architectural research: sampling methods (probability, convenience), questionnaire design (Likert scales, semantic differential), response rate optimization,
  2. Experimental designs: true experiments (random assignment, control group), quasi-experiments (non-randomized, pre-post, time series),
  3. Descriptive statistics: measures of central tendency (mean, median, mode), dispersion (standard deviation, range, interquartile range),
  4. Inferential statistics: hypothesis testing (t-test, ANOVA, chi-square), correlation and regression (linear, multiple), and interpretation of p-values
  5. Instrumentation for quantitative data collection: environmental sensors (temperature, light, \(CO_{2}\)), occupancy counters, objective performance measures (task completion time

Learning Outcomes

  1. Describe the main quantitative methods in architectural research - surveys, experiments, quasi-experiments - [Familiarity]
  2. Design a survey or experiment to test a hypothesis about the effect of a design variable (lighting, color, layout) on user satisfaction, task performance, or behavior [Usage]
  3. Evaluate a quantitative architectural study for sampling validity, statistical analysis appropriateness, and correct interpretation of p-values and effect sizes [Assessment]
3.37.4.4. Qualitative and Ethnographic Methods (12 hours) [Skills AG-A10] Back to top

Bibliography: (Creswell and Poth, 2018; Charmaz, 2014)

Topics

  1. Interviews and focus groups: structured vs. semi-structured vs. unstructured interviews, focus group dynamics, questioning strategies (probing, laddering), and recording
  2. Ethnography and observation in architecture: participant observation (researcher as user), non-participant observation (fly-on-the-wall), time-sampling behavior mapping,
  3. Content and thematic analysis: coding qualitative data (open coding, axial coding, selective coding), identifying themes
  4. Grounded theory approach in architectural research: generating theory from data rather than hypothesis testing; constant comparative method
  5. Case study methodology in architecture: single vs. multiple case design, case selection (typical, extreme, revelatory), data triangulation (documents, interviews, observations)

Learning Outcomes

  1. Describe the main qualitative methods in architectural research - interviews, focus groups, ethnography, grounded theory - [Familiarity]
  2. Conduct a qualitative study (interview, observation, or focus group) to investigate how users experience a built space, and analyze the data using thematic coding [Usage]
  3. Evaluate the rigor of a qualitative architectural study based on credibility, transferability, dependability, and confirmability criteria (Lincoln & Guba) [Assessment]

3.37.5. Bibliography Back to top

Creswell, J. W. and Creswell, J. D. (2018). Research Design: Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed Methods Approaches. SAGE Publications, 5th edition.

Groat, L. N. and Wang, D. (2013). Architectural Research Methods. Wiley, 2nd edition.

Salkind, N. J. (2017). Statistics for People Who (Think They) Hate Statistics. SAGE Publications, 6th edition.

Creswell, J. W. and Poth, C. N. (2018). Qualitative Inquiry and Research Design: Choosing Among Five Approaches. SAGE Publications, 4th edition.

Charmaz, K. (2014). Constructing Grounded Theory. SAGE Publications, 2nd edition.

Spotted a typo, an outdated course, a broken link, or have a suggestion? Let us know.

Scan to open on your phone